But in the Emmy world, you also have to see things through the Academy's eyes, not a dedicated fan's. Phase One was probably the smartest move--it got raves from several critics. The writing introduces non-viewers to the show (Kendall even makes reference to the "new recruits"). Many of us wanted the takedown of SD-6 to be much later, but to a new viewer, it would be a crowning achievement and a good twist, opening a new plot accessible to these new viewers. The Francie clone, though unrealistic, was a great surprise. The episode had great writing that will put it in the run for nominations. And the acting, too, was outstanding. Sydney and Dixon's emotions were running so high, you could feel their tears. This may be Carl Lumbly's best shot at a nod.
A Dark Turn was also a great choice, obviously aimed for Lena Olin. She really deserves a nomination, and this episode displays her talent best. Victor Garber was also great in this episode because viewers will take on a sort of "companionship" with him, and when the audience gets "betrayed by Irina," people will be able to feel with Jack. The characters really shine in this episode, specifically Jack and Irina, increasing VG's and LO's chances for a nomination (and Phase One for JG and CL).