I finally got to see I, Robot a few weeks ago. As long as a person goes into it with the frame of mind that it has nothing to do with the books then it's not a bad action movie. As I read this thread I realize that I missed a lot of movies this past summer.
But at least everytime I visit Brianw's place I get to borrow some of his DVD collection to catch up. Hopefully when I visit again in a few weeks I can swap the last batch for Aliens vs. Predator.
Aliens vs Predaotr was a lot better for me than most viewers.
you have to be in a certain frame of mind to watch it, that of the spinoff books, not the original movies. the action, posturing and script is straight out of steve perry type novels. action orientated, keeping the pace of a movie in most circumstances.