but if you've read the appendicies, you know that their story actually does go back a long way.TephieP said:I completely agree that Arwen is an annoying cow. Eowyn is sooo much cooler than arwen. And the reason that I judge Arwen is that she's barely in the book or movie. She's not a major character, so why not pair Aragorn up with someone who plays a larger role in actual plot?
And by the way, I'm Tephie P, not Tephie D. Tephie D is my best friend, though, and she doesn't like Arwen either.
*runs and screams* NOOOOOOOOOO.....Eowyn is sooooo much greater than she already was in RotK. Arwen....ha!...she doesn't even pull out a sword in the books.nance said:I didn't even catch the names during the movie because it's not very clear... so I had to read everyone's comments and Liv Tyler is Arwen and that's what I voted because I think she really really loves Aragorn and Eowyn wasn't really that cool... all she did was take out a sword and didn't fight. :blink:
*claps hands* TephieD you are absolutely right! Eowyn is so much more of an active, physical type of person, just like Aragorn. Yes, Arwen gave up her "immortality," but it's obvious Aragorn and Eowyn are much more similar and meant to be that way.TephieD said:Eowyn is SOOOOOOO much better! A million kagillion times better for Aragorn than stupid Arwen. I can't stand her! UGH! In the books she is better but in the movies she is sooo annoying. Eowyn is so clearly better for him. Who cares if she gave up her immortality for him. Eowyn loves him and would be better for him. Why doesn't Arwen go off and find her own elf and live happily ever after?